SEMI-FINALS
| Rowe's Pigskin Pros | (10-4) | | | T and A | (8-6-0) |
| QB | B. Roethlisberger | 9.33 | | QB | M. Hasselbeck | 14.75 |
| WR | L. Fitzgerald | 13.25 | | WR | H. Ward | 1.55 |
| WR | D. Branch | 2.35 | | WR | J. Galloway | 3.9 |
| WR | Ro. Williams | 9.35 | | WR | A. Johnson | 5.95 |
| RB | L. Johnson | 22.2 | | RB | T. Barber | 26.95 |
| RB | S. Gado | 2.8 | | RB | C. Williams | 2.85 |
| TE | A. Gates | 4.45 | | TE | C. Cooley | 24.55 |
| K | N. Kaeding | 12 | | K | A. Vinatieri | 4 |
| D | K. Brooking | 2.5 | | D | M. Peterson | 4.5 |
| DB | Ro. Williams | 2 | | DB | T. Polamalu | 2 |
| DL | Ja. Allen | 1.5 | | DL | K. Bulluck | 3 |
| Total | | 81.73 | | Total | | 94 |
| ECCGrounds | (9-5-0) | | | Killer B's | (8-6-0) |
| QB | T. Brady | 14.46 | | QB | T. Green | 3.57 |
| WR | C. Johnson | 16.9 | | WR | D. Driver | 4.3 |
| WR | I. Bruce | 1.8 | | WR | M. Harrison | 10.75 |
| WR | D. Givens | 16.5 | | WR | T. Holt | 8.3 |
| RB | S. Alexander | 14.6 | | RB | L. Tomlinson | 6.75 |
| RB | C. Dillon | 17.15 | | RB | D. Foster | 5.2 |
| TE | R. McMichael | 4.1 | | TE | J. Shockey | 3.15 |
| K | J. Feely | 8 | | K | M. Vanderjagt | 4 |
| D | Z. Thomas | 5 | | D | S. Quarles | 2 |
| DB | A. Wilson | 2.5 | | DB | D. Hall | 0 |
| DL | J. Trotter | 1.5 | | DL | L. Fletcher | 3 |
| Total | | 102.51 | | Total | | 51.02 |
BAGGER BOWL IV
| ECCGrounds | (9-5-0) | | | T and A | (8-6-0) |
| QB | T. Brady | 9.05 | | QB | M. Hasselbeck | 9.36 |
| WR | C. Johnson | 16.35 | | WR | H. Ward | 14.75 |
| WR | D. Givens | 2.05 | | WR | J. Galloway | 9.35 |
| WR | D. Bennett | 12 | | WR | A. Johnson | 15.55 |
| RB | S. Alexander | 25.75 | | RB | T. Barber | 9.45 |
| RB | C. Dillon | 15.85 | | RB | M. Anderson | 10.3 |
| TE | R. McMichael | 4.6 | | TE | C. Cooley | 10.55 |
| K | J. Feely | 6.5 | | K | A. Vinatieri | 6 |
| D | Z. Thomas | 3 | | D | M. Peterson | 4.5 |
| DB | A. Wilson | 6.5 | | DB | T. Polamalu | 1.5 |
| DL | J. Trotter | 4.5 | | DL | K. Bulluck | 4.5 |
| Total | | 106.15 | | Total | | 95.81 |
3rd Place
| Killer B's | (8-6-0) | | | Rowe's Pigskin Pros | (10-4-0) |
| QB | M. Brunell | 7.64 | | QB | B. Roethlisberger | 7.52 |
| WR | T. Holt | 19.15 | | WR | L. Fitzgerald | 13.15 |
| WR | J. Porter | 3.45 | | WR | D. Branch | 5.45 |
| WR | R. Brown | 6.45 | | WR | Ro. Williams | 7.55 |
| RB | L. Tomlinson | 4.85 | | RB | L. Johnson | 22.95 |
| RB | D. Foster | 5.05 | | RB | T. Fisher | 8.15 |
| TE | J. Shockey | 1.9 | | TE | A. Gates | 11.1 |
| K | M. Vanderjagt | 4 | | K | N. Kaeding | 1 |
| D | S. Quarles | 2 | | D | K. Brooking | 9 |
| DB | D. Hall | 5.5 | | DB | Ro. Williams | 4.5 |
| DL | L. Fletcher | 3.5 | | DL | Ja. Allen | 2.5 |
| Total | | 63.49 | | Total | | 92.87 |
2005 PRO BOWL RESULTS
| Team Hyla | | | | Red Tail Baggers | |
| QB | Michael Vick (AtL) | 1.3 | | QB | Carson Palmer (Cin) | 1.08 |
| WR | LaDanian Tomlinson (SD) | 11.3 | | WR | Edgerrin James (Ind) | 0 |
| WR | Shaun Alexander (Sea) | 8.65 | | WR | LaMont Jordan (Oak) | 0 |
| WR | Marvin Harrison (Ind) | 1.95 | | WR | Steve Smith (Car) | 17.4 |
| RB | Larry Fitzgerald (Ari) | 13 | | RB | Santana Moss (Was) | 6.15 |
| RB | Torry Holt (StL) | 4.1 | | RB | Anquan Boldin (Ari) | 8.05 |
| TE | Antonio Gates (SD) | 2.65 | | TE | Alge Crumpler (Atl) | 2.05 |
| K | Nate Keading (SD) | 1 | | K | Shayne Graham (Cin) | 3 |
| D | Rhonde Barber (TB) | 4 | | D | Chris Gamble (Car) | 5.5 |
| DL | Jonathan Vilma (NYJ) | 3 | | DL | Donnie Edwards (SD) | 2.5 |
| DB | Jared Allen (KC) | 2.5 | | DB | Jason Taylor (Mia) | 1 |
| Total: | | 53.45 | | Total: | | 46.73 |